What was said
What this says
Current to 11 Oct 26On 29 Jan 2025 the CFO tested the Enterprise order form total of £146k plus VAT, a capped first-term price movement and service credits. Credit control wants a reconciliation check before go-live. Signature is targeted for 14 Feb 2025.
What happened: Negotiation call on 29 Jan 2025 for a company-wide Enterprise order form. Lewis Kerr stated the total of £146k plus VAT and said it includes implementation and is not an annual figure.
Customer view: Malcolm Ridgway, the Chief Financial Officer, wants two measures, a baseline and a date to show his board. Bernadette Lowry wants a reconciliation check of the brain against the ledger before go-live, with her team choosing the sample.
Commercial: Owen Tallis offered a little room on price, first term only, capped and based on the subscription line, to be confirmed in writing. Fiona Marsden needs any movement on the order form itself, a connector schedule and the right master agreement version.
Watch: Malcolm signs only after Fiona's checklist and legal review. The call does not show whether it was signed.
Themes
Current to 9 Oct 26Who was there
BB-Demo
Them
Follow-up
Next steps
Current to 9 Oct 26- Lewis Kerr sends the revised order form, connector schedule and covering note on the day of the call.
- Owen Tallis confirms the first-term movement in writing and names the executive sponsor before signature.
- Malcolm Ridgway signs, all being well, by 14 Feb 2025.
Risks
Current to 9 Oct 26- Signature depends on the first-term price movement being confirmed in writing and the master agreement reference matching the copy legal reviewed.
- The reconciliation check may fail first time, and Bernadette expects a written answer on who changed a figure.
- A service credit does not undo a wrong stop on an account, which the CFO noted.
Opportunities
Current to 9 Oct 26- Enterprise company-wide across branch, key-account and credit control teams, with an executive sponsor and agreed measures reviewed at the first quarterly business review.
- Additional users and connectors can be added later as add-ons, co-termed to renewal.
Transcript
- Lewis Kerr NoneAfternoon, everyone. Can you all hear me alright?
- Fiona Marsden NoneYes, loud and clear, thanks Lewis.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneFine here. Is Owen joining, or is it just you today?
- Lewis Kerr NoneOwen's on his way, he's coming off another call. Ah, there he is.
- Owen Tallis NoneSorry, sorry. Afternoon all. Overran by five minutes and then the lift in our building decided to have a moment. Have I missed much?
- Lewis Kerr NoneNot a thing. We'd literally just said hello.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneAfternoon. I'll be honest, I'm only here because Malcolm asked me to be. I've got questions, and I'd rather ask them now than find out the answers later.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneRight. What's changed since the last call?
- Lewis Kerr NoneTwo things, really. First, the security review points your team raised have been answered on our side, and Fiona has those in writing. Second, the order form has been updated for the schedule changes Fiona asked for. And just so I'm clear on where we are: you want Enterprise, company-wide, so the branch teams, the key-account teams and credit control all see the same picture of each trade account, and you'd like it signed by Friday 14 February 2025. Is that still right?
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneThat's the intent. Subject to the number, and subject to what the schedule actually says.
- Owen Tallis NoneGood. Then what's the next dated step? I'd like us all to leave this call with one.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneYou'll get one. Number first.
- Lewis Kerr NoneOf course. To put a number on it, the order form total is £146,500, plus VAT. That's the total value of the deal and it includes the one-off implementation fee. It is not an annual figure, and I'd rather nobody repeated it to the board as one.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneThen split it. What's the implementation and what's the subscription?
- Lewis Kerr NoneThey're shown as separate lines on the order form. I don't want to quote them from memory on a call, so I'll put both in my covering note today and you'll have them in writing.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneYou have the document open in front of you, I assume.
- Lewis Kerr NoneI do. And I'd still rather you read them off the page than hear them off me.
- Malcolm Ridgway NonePut it in writing, then. And I'll hold you to the page. Is that the number, or is there room in it?
- Owen Tallis NoneThere's a little room, and I'll be straight about where it ends. Anything I do on price applies to the first term only, and there's a ceiling I won't go past. I'm not going to chase the total down the page today. Let's not discount twice. If we do something, we do it once, on the first term, and it falls away at renewal, and everyone knows that going in.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneA ceiling expressed as what? A percentage of what?
- Owen Tallis NoneOf the first-term subscription fee. Not the implementation, and not the total. The base is the subscription line. I'll confirm the exact movement in writing, not on this call.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneGood. I don't take a percentage without the base.
- Owen Tallis NoneUnderstood. That's why I said it.
- Fiona Marsden NoneCan I come in on that? From a procurement side, I need whatever movement there is to be visible on the order form itself, not in an email chain. If it's in an email, I can't attach it to the contract file.
- Lewis Kerr NoneThat's fair, Fiona. Anything agreed goes on the order form. The emails are just the cover.
- Fiona Marsden NoneThank you. Second point. The order form refers to the master agreement. I need it to cite the version our legal team and yours reviewed, and I need the connector list as a schedule rather than a sentence.
- Lewis Kerr NoneYes. The connectors you've named, the CRM, the accounting system, the helpdesk and the call recorder, are each written in, and each carries a commitment to go live within a set number of days of the start. So that's contractual, not a hope.
- Fiona Marsden NoneAnd if one slips?
- Lewis Kerr NoneThen the order form says what happens. I'd point you to the service levels schedule, because I think that's where Bernadette's question sits as well.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneIt does. So I know what I'm being sold: if the overnight load fails and my team chases an account on stop using yesterday's figures, what happens?
- Lewis Kerr NoneEnterprise is the tier that's credited for both availability and data freshness. The nightly refresh is due to be complete by 07:00 your local time on business days. If it isn't, that's a breach for the month, and a service credit applies against that month's fee.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneA credit doesn't unstop an account. It doesn't un-chase a customer either.
- Lewis Kerr NoneNo, you're right, it doesn't. The credit is the money remedy. The practical one is that you can see on the page when the data was last refreshed, so your team knows what they're looking at before they pick up the phone.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneI'll believe it when it reconciles. The ledger says otherwise more often than people admit. When your thing says a trade account is fine and the statement says it's overdue, which one do I trust?
- Owen Tallis NoneThe ledger. Always. The brain reads from the accounting system, and the accounting system stays the source of truth. If the two disagree, that's a data problem we investigate, and it's exactly what we'd want to find during implementation, not a year in.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneWho changed that, though? If a figure moves, can I see who or what moved it?
- Lewis Kerr NoneI'd want our solutions engineer to answer that properly rather than have me guess. What I can say is that it runs inside your own Snowflake account, so your team controls access and can see what's there. I'll get you a written answer on how changes are traced.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneWritten. Fine. And before go-live I want a reconciliation check. A sample of trade accounts, branch by branch, the brain against the ledger, signed off by my team. Not a demo with tidy data.
- Owen Tallis NoneThat's reasonable, and I'd rather agree it now than argue about it later. We can write a reconciliation check against a sample of your accounts into the implementation plan as an acceptance step. I'd want your team to choose the sample, not us.
- Malcolm Ridgway NonePut it in the schedule.
- Owen Tallis NoneIt goes in the schedule.
- Lewis Kerr NoneLet me put the order form on screen so we're all looking at the same thing. Malcolm, the service levels are the last schedule. I'll scroll down to it now.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneGive me a minute. I'm reading it, not skimming it.
- Lewis Kerr NoneTake your time.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneParagraph on service credits. It says a credit for each month with a breach. A credit of what, against what?
- Owen Tallis NoneA proportion of one month's fee, for each month with a breach. The base is the monthly share of the subscription, not the implementation. The proportion is written on the page, third line down.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneThird line. Yes, I see it. And that's the same for availability and for freshness?
- Lewis Kerr NoneSame mechanism, and as I said it's Enterprise that gets freshness covered as well. The lower tiers are credited for availability only.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneFine. Payment. We're a wholesaler, we live on trade credit in both directions. What are your terms, and what does the shape of the invoicing do to my cash across the year?
- Lewis Kerr NoneStandard is the subscription invoiced annually in advance, on thirty-day terms. Quarterly invoicing is available on request.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneAnd the cost of that is?
- Lewis Kerr NoneMy understanding is that it's a billing arrangement rather than a price change, but I won't say that from memory. I'll confirm it in the covering note, so you have it in writing.
- Owen Tallis NoneTo save you a round trip: it's a billing arrangement. The total on the order form stays as it is, and the invoices simply come in quarterly instalments. Lewis will still put it on the page.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneAnd the implementation?
- Owen Tallis NoneA one-off, fixed fee, invoiced separately from the subscription. It runs for twelve weeks from the start.
- Fiona Marsden NoneIs the security review support inside that fee, or on top?
- Lewis Kerr NoneInside it. For Enterprise, security review support is part of the implementation line, so there's no separate charge for it.
- Fiona Marsden NoneGood. Right, the master agreement version. Let me pull up the one our legal team reviewed. Bear with me, it's in a folder I never remember the name of.
- Lewis Kerr NoneNo rush.
- Fiona Marsden NoneSorry, that took longer than it should have. I have it. The one we reviewed is the copy our legal team marked as final. Does your reference on the order form point at that same copy?
- Lewis Kerr NoneIt should do, but I'm not going to say yes without checking the file against yours. I'll compare them this afternoon and confirm in writing, and if there's any difference I'll tell you before the order form goes anywhere near a signature.
- Fiona Marsden NoneThat's all I need. Thank you.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneNow the part I actually care about. The board will ask what they got for this. What do I show them, and when?
- Owen Tallis NoneFair question. We agree two or three measures at the kickoff, things your own teams will recognise: how many questions the branch and credit control teams ask the brain, and how long it takes to get to the bottom of a disputed invoice. Then we review them with you at the first quarterly business review after go-live.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneI'm not interested in features. I've sat through the features. I want the two measures, the baseline and the date.
- Owen Tallis NoneThen that's what we write down. The baseline comes from your side, from what the teams do today, and the review date goes in the plan. You'd also have an executive sponsor on our side as part of Enterprise, so there's a named senior person who owns that conversation with you.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneNamed. In writing.
- Owen Tallis NoneNamed, in writing, before signature.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneWhile we're on baselines. I'll choose the sample for the reconciliation check with my team, and I'll give you the criteria. I won't put any account's credit position in an email to sales. If we need to look at real accounts, we do it in a working session with the right people in the room.
- Lewis Kerr NoneUnderstood, and that's the right way round. Criteria by email, accounts in the session. I'll make sure the plan says the same.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneAnd when the check fails, because it will the first time, I want the answer to the question of who changed that, not a shrug.
- Owen Tallis NoneThen that's the point of doing it before go-live. We find the awkward ones early, with your team looking, and we fix the source rather than the symptom.
- Fiona Marsden NoneOne more from me, since we're listing things. The users. How many people are covered, and what happens if the branches add more later?
- Lewis Kerr NoneThe user and connector allowances are on the first page of the order form, and I'd rather you read the exact numbers there than hear them from me. If you outgrow them, additional users and additional connectors are available as add-ons, and I'd quote those separately, co-termed to your renewal, so nothing is a surprise.
- Fiona Marsden NoneCo-termed. Good. That's what I wanted to hear.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneLet me say where I am. The price I'll take away and read in the covering note. The schedule is readable. The service credits I understand, and I'd note they don't undo a wrong stop on an account. Bernadette's reconciliation check goes in. Fiona's points go in. What else could stop this being signed by Friday 14 February 2025?
- Owen Tallis NoneFrom our side, nothing I can see, provided the price movement is agreed in writing and the master agreement reference matches. Who signs?
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneI do. After Fiona has been through her checklist and legal have seen the final order form. Not before.
- Fiona Marsden NoneWhich means I need the revised order form with the schedules attached, and I need it early enough to give legal a proper look. A couple of days isn't enough for them.
- Lewis Kerr NoneYou'll have it today. Revised order form, the connector schedule, the reconciliation check in the plan, and my covering note with the implementation and subscription lines set out separately and the VAT position on each.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneAnd the movement on the first term?
- Owen Tallis NoneIn the order form, once I've confirmed it. I'll do that tomorrow, and Lewis will fold it into a second version so you aren't reading two documents against each other.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneOne version. I'll read one version.
- Lewis Kerr NoneOne version it is.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneThe written answer on tracing changes. When?
- Lewis Kerr NoneI'll ask our solutions engineer today and aim to have it with you before the end of the week.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneBefore the end of the week. I'll hold you to it, and I'll read it with the ledger open next to it.
- Owen Tallis NoneFair. I'd expect nothing less.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneAnything else on timing? If I sign on that Friday, when does anything actually switch on?
- Lewis Kerr NoneAfter signature, the kickoff is the first step. We agree owners for each connector, your side and ours, and the plan sets out the twelve weeks. Amara Obi, our customer success manager, picks up from the kickoff and stays with you after go-live.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneAmara. Fine. I'd like her in the room for the kickoff, not just on the email.
- Lewis Kerr NoneI'll make sure of it.
- Owen Tallis NoneLet me read back the dated steps so we're all holding the same list. Lewis sends the revised order form and the covering note today. I confirm the first-term movement in writing tomorrow, and you get one final version. Lewis checks the master agreement reference against Fiona's file and confirms this afternoon. The written answer on tracing changes goes to Bernadette before the end of the week. Fiona takes the order form to legal. Malcolm reads the schedule and signs, all being well, by Friday 14 February 2025. Have I missed anything?
- Fiona Marsden NoneThe named executive sponsor, in writing, before signature.
- Owen Tallis NoneYes, that too. Thank you. I'll send that name myself.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneAnd the criteria for the sample are mine to send. I'll have them to Lewis early next week.
- Lewis Kerr NonePerfect. I'll attach them to the plan as soon as they arrive.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneThen I don't think there's anything left for this call. I'd rather read than talk. Send it over.
- Lewis Kerr NoneWill do. Thanks, everyone, I appreciate the time, and the straight questions.
- Fiona Marsden NoneThanks, Lewis. Thanks, Owen. Speak soon.
- Owen Tallis NoneThanks all. Speak next week.
- Bernadette Lowry NoneRight. I'll be waiting for that email, then.
- Malcolm Ridgway NoneGoodbye.
- Lewis Kerr NoneOwen, stay on a second, if you can. I want to make sure I have the movement conversation straight before I write it up.
- Owen Tallis NoneSure. Go on.
- Lewis Kerr NoneSo the movement is first term only, on the subscription line, and it comes with the ceiling you named. I'm not putting a figure in the covering note until you've confirmed it tomorrow.
- Owen Tallis NoneCorrect. Keep the note clean. Total, the two lines separately, VAT position, billing in quarterly instalments if they want it, and the date. Nothing about any other customer, and nothing from memory.
- Lewis Kerr NoneUnderstood. I'll also update the CRM with the stage and the date tonight, so the close date is the one Malcolm gave us and not a hopeful one.
- Owen Tallis NoneGood. Friday 14 February 2025 is the date, and the next dated step is the version in Fiona's hands today. If that slips, tell me the same day.
- Lewis Kerr NoneWill do. I'll send that over today.
- Owen Tallis NoneThanks, Lewis. Speak later.